Is Your Boiler on Its Last Legs? Here's How to Tell

When your boiler starts playing up, the big question is always the same: repair or replace? After 27 years in the heating industry, I've seen countless homeowners pour money into repairs for boilers that were already past their best. Here are seven clear signs that it's time to invest in a new boiler rather than throwing good money after bad.

‍

1. Your Boiler Is Over 15 Years Old

Age matters more than you think

If your boiler has been faithfully serving you for 15 years or more, it's living on borrowed time. Modern boilers are far more efficient—often 90%+ compared to 60-70% for older models. Even if yours is still working, you're likely spending hundreds extra on energy bills each year. A new Worcester Bosch boiler typically pays for itself within 5-7 years through energy savings alone.

‍

2. Repairs Are Becoming Frequent

The expensive cycle

One repair is unfortunate. Two or three in a year? That's a pattern. When I'm called out repeatedly to the same property, I always have an honest conversation with homeowners about the maths. If you're spending £300-500 annually on repairs, that's £1,500-2,500 over five years—money that could go towards a reliable new installation instead.

‍

3. Your Energy Bills Keep Rising

Even when your usage hasn't changed, climbing bills often signal declining efficiency. Boilers lose efficiency as components wear out, meaning they work harder (and cost more) to heat your home to the same temperature. If your bills have crept up significantly over the past few years, your boiler is likely the culprit.

‍

4. Cold Spots on Radiators

A warning sign

Cold patches on radiators—especially at the bottom—indicate sludge build up in your system. While powerflushing can help, if your boiler is also struggling, it may not be worth treating an old system. Sludge damages boiler components, and if the damage is done, a flush is just delaying the inevitable.

‍

5. The Boiler Makes Unusual Noises

Banging, whistling, or gurgling sounds aren't normal. These noises often indicate limescale buildup, failing pumps, or air in the system. In Chichester's hard water area, limescale is particularly problematic for older boilers. When these issues coincide with other problems, replacement becomes the sensible option.

‍

6. You're Struggling to Find Parts

Obsolete models

Older boilers become obsolete, and manufacturers stop producing spare parts. If I'm telling you parts are hard to source or need ordering specially, that's a red flag. You don't want to be left in the cold mid-winter waiting for a part that may not even be available.

‍

7. The Pilot Light Keeps Going Out

Yellow flames spell trouble

A pilot light that frequently cuts out or burns yellow instead of blue could indicate incomplete combustion—a potential carbon monoxide risk. This is a safety issue requiring immediate Gas Safe attention. If it's a recurring problem with an older boiler, replacement is the safe, sensible choice.

‍

Making the Right Decision

If you're experiencing two or more of these signs, it's time for an honest assessment. As a Gas Safe registered engineer with 20 years of self-employment, I always give straight advice about whether repair or replacement makes financial sense.

A new, efficient boiler brings reliability, lower bills, and peace of mind—no more wondering if you'll wake up to a cold house.

Need expert advice on your boiler? Call Selsey Heating for a free, no-obligation assessment across Selsey, Chichester, Bracklesham Bay, West Wittering, East Wittering and the surrounding area.